Melanie mitchell is a professor of computer science at portland state university. We can imagine every bit of music perception as analogymaking, from recognizing a simple, primitive sound a single note or a simple. Creativity and artificial intelligence sciencedirect. Perception and analogymaking in visual understanding. Pdf architecture for analogical reasoning in a bongard. Incorporating selfwatching into a computer model of highlevel perception and analogymaking james b. Analogymaking as perception is based on the premise that analogymaking is fundamentally a highlevel perceptual process in which the interaction of. Both the situation perception and mapping processes are essential to analogymaking, but of the two the former is more fundamental, for the simple reason that the mapping process requires. By examining secondary iconicity in sensory vocabulary, this study draws attention to diagrammatic qualities in human interaction with, and representation. It lies behind basic tasks such as the identification of places, objects and people, for example, in face perception and facial recognition systems. Contributed article a neural network theory of proportional. The mathematical infrastructure consists of a basic category of artificial. The interplay of analogymaking with active vision and. This paper formalizes and analyzes cognitive transitions between artificial perceptions that consist of an analogical or metaphorical transference of perception.
Therefore, the problems of relational representation and relational reasoning are central to models of analogy making. Decisionmaking and strategic thinking through analogies. Github repository of copycat implementation and other farg projects the copycat project. The research reported in this thesis concentrates on analogymaking. Professional employment davis professor, santa fe institute, 20202021.
Learning to make analogies by contrasting abstract relational. This is achieved by combining sparse bottom up visual perception performed by the ikaros system. Therefore, ambr is presented and discussed here as a model of analogymaking regardless of the fact that some of the considerations may have broader scope. Having accepted but wavering as to what to say, i finally chose to eschew technicalities and instead to convey a. This work explores some of the most fundamental questions of artificial intelligence. The centrality and the ubiquity of analogy in creative thought have been noted again and again by scientists, artists, and writers, and understanding and modeling analogical thought have emerged as two of the most important challenges for cognitive science.
Analogymaking as a complex adaptive system melanie mitchell. Analogy perception and creativity mechanisms springerlink. Creativity is a fundamental feature of human intelligence, and a challenge for ai. The copycat project 35 to conceive of, say, the successor or predecessor relation as an idealized version of any nonidentity relationship in a realworld domain, such as parent of, neighbor of, friend of, employed by, close to, etc. Ai techniques can be used to create new ideas in three ways. The models of analogymaking typically decompose it into separate stages or phases. Perceive this as that analogies, artificial perception, and. Introduction analogymaking is, without question, one of the most singularly important ways in which children gradually make sense of their world. Analogymaking as perception neural network modeling and. Ambr models analogy as emergent phenomena it emerges from the local interactions of a large number of microagents. By examining secondary iconicity in sensory vocabulary, this study draws attention to diagrammatic qualities in human interaction with, and representation of, the sensory world. Download analogymaking as perception neural network modeling and connectionism books download as pdf.
The following are the proceedings of the third international workshop on human and machine perception held in pavia, italy, on september 14 17, 1998. Analogy as the core of cognition stuyvesant high school. Consequently, mechanisms involved in the creativity are seen as analogy perception processes. Analogymaking as perception is based on the premise that analogymaking is fundamentally. Anxiety can influence analogymaking both positively and. Given this viewpoint about analogy, it is natural to try to apply it to the particular case of analogymaking in music perception. The research described in this book is based on the premise that human analogymaking is an extension of our constant background process of perceivingin other words, that analogymaking and the perception of sameness are two sides of the same coin. Dynamic extension of episode representation in analogymaking. This particular class of visual patternrecognition problems was introduced in 1970 by the russian intelligence theorist mikhail m. This means that analogy making both makes use of many different cognitive processes such as perception, memory, learning, etc. Request pdf a selfwatching model of analogymaking and perception this paper describes metacat, an extension of the copycat model of analogymaking. A model of mental fluidity and analogy making douglas r. Click pdf analogymaking as perception neural network modeling and connectionism. Learning to make analogies by contrasting abstract.
I am tempted to avoid the word, to jump directly into interspecies relationships or interspecies pedagogy and the place of analogy making in these processes. As a result, a given set of input data may be perceived in a. This particular class of visual patternrecognition problems was introduced in 1970 by the russian. The centrality and the ubiquity of analogy in creative. It describes copycat a computer model of analogymaking, developed by the author with douglas. A neural network theory of proportional analogymaking. Foreword by daniel dennett while it is fashionable today to dismiss the bad old days of artificial intelligence and rave about emergent self. Gilles fauconnier chapter 7, this volume integrates analogy with conceptual blending. The interplay of analogymaking with active vision and motor control in anticipatory behaviour. Analogy can be viewed as a type of reasoning where knowledge is. In our view, analogy is not separate from perception. This thesis describes an architecture implementing the. Analogymaking is so intimately and so deeply part of human cognition that it is probably safe to say that any program capable of doing analogymaking in a manner truly comparable to.
This edition has been under the auspices of two institutions. Computational analogy making in designing 3 component is a set of actions for transforming the input into the output, typically represented as a set of subordinate processes which can, in turn, be modelled in terms of their function, behaviour and structure gero and kannengiesser 2006. Douglas hofstadter chapter 15, this volume argues that analogymaking might be the core of many cognitive processes from perception to categorization to translation of poetry. Here, we study how analogical reasoning can be induced in neural networks that learn to perceive and reason about raw visual data.
Her major work has been in the areas of analogical reasoning, complex systems, genetic algorithms and cellular automata, and her publications in those fields are frequently cited. Hofstadter once upon a time, i was invited to speak at an analogy workshop in the legendary city of sofia in the faroff land of bulgaria. This is achieved by combining sparse bottom up visual perception. The capacity for making and learning analogies is clearly at the heart of advanced human cognitive capabilities and of creativity holyoak and thagard, 1995, indurkhya, 1991, lakoff and johnson, 1980. The interaction of the processes of mapping and perception. Dynamic extension of episode representation in analogymaking in ambr. The perceptual and domaincomparison components of our models are connected and jointly optimised endtoend, which, as posited by hlp, re.
Perceive this as that analogies, artificial perception. However, analogymaking involves not only choosing among various potential relational matches, but is a much more complicated process that integrates perception and encoding of the existing relations in the environment among the many possible relations some are relevant for. It is typical both for everyday commonsense reasoni ng and for highly creative thinking. Analogy plays a significant role in problem solving, as well as decision making, argumentation, perception, generalization, memory, creativity, invention, prediction, emotion, explanation, conceptualization and communication. There is no general agreement on what is analogymaking. The ambr model of analogy making is used as a basis, but it is extended with new mechanisms for anticipation related to analogical transfer, for top down perception and selective attention. It shows the relation between various elements involved in analogy making. Architecture for analogical reasoning in a bongardproblem solver. Pdf analogymaking as perception a computer model semantic. Analogymaking as perception neural network modeling and connectionism detail books. We can imagine every bit of music perception as analogy making, from recognizing a simple, primitive sound a single note or a simple. Analogymaking in the semai sensory world sylvia tufvesson abstract in the interplay between language, culture, and perception, iconicity structures our representations of what we experience. An analogymaking model with rerepresentation capabilities needs the support of a full cognitive architecture that implements all the assumptions above.
Architecture for analogical reasoning in a bongardproblem. In proceedings of the annual meeting of the cognitive science society, volume 23, 2001. Computational analogymaking in designing 3 component is a set of actions for transforming the input into the output, typically represented as a set of subordinate processes which can, in turn, be modelled in terms of their function, behaviour and structure gero and kannengiesser 2006. Read analogymaking as perception pdf a computer model neural network modeling and connectionism ebook by melanie mitchell. Metamagical themas download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Analogymaking as perception melanie mitchell a computer. The bottom up visual processing is performed by the ikaros system for brain modeling. Perception and analogy making in visual understanding introduction. Book reads or downloads analogymaking as perception neural network modeling and connectionism now.
Analogymaking as perception is based on the premise that analogymaking is fundamentally a highlevel perceptual process in which the interaction of perception and concepts gives rise to conceptual slippages which allow analogies to be made. Thus, highlevel perception is bound to the problem of mental representation. An example of such an analogy might be if abc changes to abd, how does iijjkk change in. Introduction analogy making is, without question, one of the most singularly important ways in which children gradually make sense of their world. A selfwatching model of analogymaking and perception james b. Professor, portland state university, department of computer science, 2004present. Professional employment professor, portland state university, department of computer science, 904present. Given this viewpoint about analogy, it is natural to try to apply it to the particular case of analogy making in music perception. External professor, santa fe institute, 2000present. The cognitive architecture dual is specifically designed to support this decentralized and interactive style of computation kokinov, 1994b, 1994c, 1997. Analogymaking as perception model of mitchell and hofstadter 1990 for solving bongard problems. As mentioned, other analogymaking systems generally receive as input a set of. Analogy making as perception is based on the premise that analogy making is fundamentally.
The lessons of almost 40 years of research in the computational modeling of analogymaking have, more than anything else, shown us just how hard the problem is. Bongard and still represents a formidable challenge for ai research. A computer model of highlevel perception and conceptual slippage in analogymaking. Although the analogy making is recognized as a complex process composed of and relating to other cognitive processes this relationship remains more or less unclear. Contributed article a neural network theory of proportional analogymaking nilendu g. Perception and analogymaking in visual understanding introduction.
Analogy making is a basic human ability which lies at the heart of human cognition. Pdf highlevel perception, representation, and analogy. Abstractin the interplay between language, culture, and perception, iconicity structures our representations of what we experience. Analogymaking as perception philosophical arguments for and against modularity chalmers et al, 1992. The formalization is performed within a mathematical framework that has been used before to formalize other aspects of artificial perception and cognition. Analogymaking can be defined as the perception of two or more nonidentical objects or situations as being the same at. Unification of clustering, concept formation, categorization, and analogy making harry e. Analogy making as perception is based on the premise that analogy making is fundamentally a highlevel perceptual process in which the interaction of perception and concepts gives rise to conceptual slippages which allow analogies to be made. A selfwatching model of analogy making and perception james b. Unification of clustering, concept formation, categorization. In semai monkhmer, aslian, spoken on peninsular malaysia, sensory experiences are.
A selfwatching model of analogymaking and perception. Copycat perceives analogies between short strings of letters, which can be thought of as representing abstract situations in an idealized microworld. Analogy problems in the copycat domain copycat is a computer program designed to be able to discover insightful analogies, and to do so in a psychologically realistic way. However, analogy making involves not only choosing among various potential relational matches, but is a much more complicated process that integrates perception and encoding of the existing relations in the environment among the many possible relations some are relevant for. The psychologist william james observed that a native talent for perceiving analogies is.
891 497 874 403 477 1284 1543 594 66 780 110 883 1155 134 26 74 1490 1578 153 637 28 1357 136 1137 1343 416 723 31 226 735